The Real Inspiration And Evolution Of The Betty Boop Cartoon

A Decision Is Made

The trial dragged on for two long years. Finally, Max Fleischer was able to locate a sound film from 1928 of Baby Esther performing, which included some “boop-a-doops.” That was enough evidence for Judge Edward J. McGoldrick to make his decision. He ruled that the plaintiff had “failed to sustain either cause of action by proof of sufficient probative force.” His opinion was that the “baby” style of singing did not originate with Helen Kane and that she was not the basis of Betty Boop’s appearance since Boop resembled other actresses, such as Clara Bow.